Difference between revisions of "Why do I am alook alike a poss of porter pease?"
(7 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
* '''to look as like as two peas in a pod:''' (''phrase'') to appear identical → the two peas could be used to represent the twins [[Shem]] and [[Shaun]] | * '''to look as like as two peas in a pod:''' (''phrase'') to appear identical → the two peas could be used to represent the twins [[Shem]] and [[Shaun]] | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''porter Pees:''' in William Langland's ''Piers Ploughman'' (incidentally which also contains references to Robin Hood and his men, → [[Mulk mountynotty man]]) B.xx.296: Peace ("Pees") is set up as porter to bolt the gates of church Unity to all idle gossipers and men with evil intent: "In Unitee holy chirche / Conscience held hym, / And made Pees porter / To pynne the yates, / Of alle tale-telleris / And titeleris in ydel". .. Peace later interrogates Sir Creeps-into-houses ("Sire Penetrans-domos") who attempts to gain entrance. Peace attempts to keep him out, but Courteous Speech ("Hende-speche") convinces Peace to open up the door for him, with disastrous results → [[handworded]] | ||
* '''peascod''' → cf. the custom of placing a peascod with nine peas in it on the door-lintel to attract a husband | * '''peascod''' → cf. the custom of placing a peascod with nine peas in it on the door-lintel to attract a husband | ||
Line 6: | Line 8: | ||
* '''poss:''' to wash (clothes) in a poss-tub | * '''poss:''' to wash (clothes) in a poss-tub | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''poss:''' (''Dialect'') waterfall | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''poss:''' (''Latin'') can (that is, 'able to', but a play on words as in 'can of porter') | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''Possen:''' (''German'') prank, trick | ||
* '''a pot of porter:''' porter is the type of alcoholic drink of which Guinness is the best known example | * '''a pot of porter:''' porter is the type of alcoholic drink of which Guinness is the best known example | ||
* '''porter:''' a door-keeper | * '''porter:''' a door-keeper | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''porter:''' (''French'') carry (the Prankquean, in her petty perusienne, is about to carry Tristopher away) | ||
* '''Piesporter:''' wine from Piesport in Germany | * '''Piesporter:''' wine from Piesport in Germany | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''P's''' | ||
+ | |||
+ | * '''pees:''' HCE's crime often involves urination | ||
* '''please''' | * '''please''' | ||
Line 34: | Line 48: | ||
The riddle sounds like: ''Why do I and a poss of porter look as alike as two peas in a pod?'' | The riddle sounds like: ''Why do I and a poss of porter look as alike as two peas in a pod?'' | ||
+ | |||
+ | Taking different elements of the phrasing of the riddle, we can extract various questions relevant to the situation such as: | ||
+ | *1) ''Why am I like a pot of pease porridge?'' The answer being that she is both ''hot'' (angry for being left outside) and ''cold''. | ||
+ | *2) ''How do I get past the porter, please?'' (The Manservant as doorkeeper/porter not letting her in → [[keep of his inn]]) | ||
+ | *3) ''Who do you take me for? I'd like a poss (that is 'wash') of porter (the drink), please?'' |
Latest revision as of 03:27, 22 February 2020
- to look as like as two peas in a pod: (phrase) to appear identical → the two peas could be used to represent the twins Shem and Shaun
- porter Pees: in William Langland's Piers Ploughman (incidentally which also contains references to Robin Hood and his men, → Mulk mountynotty man) B.xx.296: Peace ("Pees") is set up as porter to bolt the gates of church Unity to all idle gossipers and men with evil intent: "In Unitee holy chirche / Conscience held hym, / And made Pees porter / To pynne the yates, / Of alle tale-telleris / And titeleris in ydel". .. Peace later interrogates Sir Creeps-into-houses ("Sire Penetrans-domos") who attempts to gain entrance. Peace attempts to keep him out, but Courteous Speech ("Hende-speche") convinces Peace to open up the door for him, with disastrous results → handworded
- peascod → cf. the custom of placing a peascod with nine peas in it on the door-lintel to attract a husband
- Alike: (Greek) Alice → Alice Pleasance Liddell, the girl who inspired Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass; → Alice and her image in the looking glass, or mirror, look alike → ALP
- poss: to wash (clothes) in a poss-tub
- poss: (Dialect) waterfall
- poss: (Latin) can (that is, 'able to', but a play on words as in 'can of porter')
- Possen: (German) prank, trick
- a pot of porter: porter is the type of alcoholic drink of which Guinness is the best known example
- porter: a door-keeper
- porter: (French) carry (the Prankquean, in her petty perusienne, is about to carry Tristopher away)
- Piesporter: wine from Piesport in Germany
- P's
- pees: HCE's crime often involves urination
- please
- pease: (nursery rhyme) Pease porridge hot, Pease porridge cold, Pease porridge in the pot Nine days old. Spell me that without a P, And a clever scholar you will be → the answer, of course, is THAT
Commentary
This is the first of the Prankquean's 3 riddles. Here are the riddles in order:
1. Mark the wans, why do I am alook alike a poss of porterpease?
2. Mark the Twy, why do I am alook alike two poss of porterpease?
3. Mark the Tris, why do I am alook alike three poss of porter pease?
The threefold form of the riddles (wans, twy, tris) is a charm motif that is used elsewhere in FW (e.g. in the tales How Kerrse Made A Suit of Clothes for the Norwegian Captain and How Buckley Shot the Russian General). It is used in "the fairytale pattern of three tries and a magic opening" (Margeret C. Solomon, Eternal Geomater).
The Prankquean (ALP) seems to Jarl van Hoother (HCE) a riddle; at the same time she asks him for a drink, just as Grace O'Malley sought hospitality from the Lord of Howth in the original story.
The riddle sounds like: Why do I and a poss of porter look as alike as two peas in a pod?
Taking different elements of the phrasing of the riddle, we can extract various questions relevant to the situation such as:
- 1) Why am I like a pot of pease porridge? The answer being that she is both hot (angry for being left outside) and cold.
- 2) How do I get past the porter, please? (The Manservant as doorkeeper/porter not letting her in → keep of his inn)
- 3) Who do you take me for? I'd like a poss (that is 'wash') of porter (the drink), please?